José Manuel Torralba, IMDEA MATERIALS
When engineers design materials for a specific application, we do so according to standards that specify the properties those materials must possess to withstand the most demanding service conditions.
If we consider a railway rail, it may be exposed to corrosion, wear, and, above all, dynamic stresses that can lead to fatigue damage. Combining all these properties is not straightforward, which is why, when designing and manufacturing rail steel, it is essential to strike a balance and focus on the potential consequences of failure associated with each requirement.
Corrosion and wear can create defects that are readily detectable during inspections, which do not necessarily need to be conducted very frequently, since such damage would not cause the rail to fail catastrophically over a short period of time (weeks or months).
Dynamic stresses are a different matter. If a material exceeds its fatigue limit – the number of stress cycles it can endure before a crack begins to form – a crack will appear and start growing, initially slowly, until it reaches a critical size. Once that critical size is reached, the crack can grow so rapidly that it may cause catastrophic failure within minutes, or even seconds.
Steel Is the Most Reliable Material of All
The idea that a railway accident such as the one that recently occurred in Adamuz was caused by “poor-quality” steel is highly unlikely, for several reasons. To begin with, steel is, without question, the most reliable of all structural materials: if one hundred test specimens are examined, all one hundred will fall within an extremely narrow margin of error.
In the case of rail steels, we are talking about steels with tightly controlled chemical compositions that satisfy the required mechanical properties while also ensuring weldability. Engineers, who certify projects with their signatures, use very large safety margins and quality standards to ensure that materials never approach their fatigue limits. These margins are established through international standards.
The manufacturers of the steels involved in the accident (one older and one recently produced) have manufactured thousands of kilometres of rail in accordance with highly stringent standards and extreme quality-assurance requirements. These rails have operated without problems. They are produced from standards-compliant, weldable steel and are designed to withstand the static load of trains weighing several hundred tonnes. Even when trains travel at 250 km/h, the dynamic stresses generated remain far below the rails’ fatigue limit.
If the steel has been properly manufactured, and quality certifications confirm this, it is extremely unlikely that it would fail under normal service conditions.
Welding Under Scrutiny
So what should we expect from the weld?
Railway rails are joined using a process known as thermite welding, which ensures metallic continuity through a weld metal whose composition closely resembles that of the rails being connected.
It appears that, in the specific section of track where the Adamuz accident occurred, rails made from steels of different compositions were joined. However, both rails were manufactured from highly weldable steels, meaning it is very unlikely that embrittlement occurred within the so-called heat-affected zone. Had this been the case, an accident would likely have happened much earlier.
A weld can “cause problems” if it is executed improperly, but quality is ensured in two ways. First, welding is carried out only by certified welders. Second, every weld is inspected individually, both visually and using techniques that allow inspectors to examine the weld internally. As a result, when a railway line is commissioned, all welds are certified as having been correctly executed.
How the Impossible May Have Happened
Despite all this, one of the hypotheses being considered in the Adamuz disaster is that a weld failed and a section of rail fractured catastrophically.
How could this have happened if it was supposed to be impossible?
If metallic continuity is lost because a weld fails and the two rail sections become separated, every wheel passing over that location will impose stresses near the rail ends far greater than the design stress. Eventually, the fatigue limit could be exceeded, causing a crack to form. The crack would then grow, and once it exceeded a critical size, catastrophic fracture would occur. And what might have happened to the weld?
At this point, all indications suggest either that there was a flaw in the design of the welding material itself (there is currently discussion of a potentially inappropriate material selection caused by an error in the technical specifications) or that an extremely small defect was introduced during welding and went undetected during the post-weld inspection. Of course, other explanations remain possible, but it would be premature to assume negligence or poor practice without a proper forensic investigation.
Prevention Is Better Than Cure
When we are young, many bodily systems work reliably and regular medical check-ups are unnecessary; we go to the doctor only when something hurts. The doctor then uses various diagnostic tools to identify and treat the problem. As we grow older, however, we cannot afford to wait for symptoms to become obvious. We undergo increasingly frequent check-ups to prevent minor problems from developing into catastrophic failures.
Something similar may have happened in Adamuz. The accident might have been avoided if the warning signs had been taken seriously. Both passengers and some railway workers had reportedly been noticing unusual vibrations for months, and appropriate inspections could have been carried out.
We still do not know exactly what happened. We must await the final conclusions of the experts. Fortunately, metallurgical engineers possess the tools, techniques, and expertise needed to investigate such failures in great detail, much like a forensic pathologist can determine the precise cause of death. I have no doubt that the cause of the failure, and its impact on the rest of the infrastructure, will soon be fully understood. The resulting report should also clarify whether the accident could have been prevented.
José Manuel Torralba, Full Professor, Carlos III University of Madrid, Senior Researcher, IMDEA MATERIALES
This article was originally published in The Conversation. Read the original.